Results
Judge #1
"I tried to be as realistic as possible and I thought I was too harsh"
Practicality - 6/10
Creativity - 2/5
Originality - 2/5
Total: 10
Judge #2
~ Practicality - 5 - I am not sure if someone were to see this flying from above they would feel these people were in need of help. I mean you have someone training for the olympics, someone doing yoga, a guy with a crown carrying another guy like a baby and a girl juggling mangos. This doesn't scream "HELP" to me like an SOS should.
~ Creativity - 2 - I want to join the party more than save the victims. I think the creativity just went the wrong direction.
~ Originality - 2 - I am not sure anything super unique was done here.
Total: 9
Judge #3
I audibly laughed immediately when I saw it, so we're off to a good start! Where are the mangoes, that was the funniest item! Nitwits. Anyways, I mean, if I saw such a burly man on a flag pole like that, I feel like I would see the signal from above, but like, otherwise this is pretty dismal. In terms of creativity, it's alright, nothing special, I feel like you added items to get comedic effect to castaways instead of using it as the SOS signal, the only real original thing is the coach swinging like a monkey man. This looks more like a "camp life" competition photo than an SOS signal comp.
Practicality: 5
Creativity: 3
Originality: 2
Total: 10
Grand Total: 23 (29 - 6 points of deductions: Missed Selection Time, Shane not collecting, Not using all items -- Mangoes)
Judge #1
"I tried to be as realistic as possible and I thought I was too harsh"
practicality - 8/10
creativity - 3/5
originality - 3/5
Total: 14
Judge #2
~ Practicality - 6 - I am not sure it would necessarily be seen but at least you included some sort of SOS message. [Despite using more coconuts than you had] That being said.. UFO's??? WTF
~ Creativity - 3 - Visually it is the most realistic but I think more could have been done.
~ Originality - 2 - Not sure it is that unique, I guess the UFO's could be unique but if you have a flying object.. why not fly the hell out of there?
Total: 11
Judge #3
I wasn't as immediately entertained but now since I'm judging I suppose I should look more into your photo. I gotta give you guys props for actually including all your items to exact number value, I wouldn't have patience for that. In terms of a signal, y'all don't even need help Cochran's got u sorted with that UFO, but otherwise I'd say it's a solid signal. The cutouts are smooth, with the exception of the fire and Abi(?)'s leg. I'd say overall this was pretty well done, it's not really original in terms of a signal, but hey - it gets the job done.
Practicality: 8
Creativity: 4
Originality: 2
Total: 14
Grand Total: 31 (39 - 8 points of deductions: Elyse and Pete not collecting, 2 missed selection times)
_____________________________________________________________
So with that let's make it official. The winners of this challenge are...
Congratulations Malaga, you have won Immunity and are safe from Tribal Council. This also earns you access to Treasure Trove and the opportunity to earn the powers available.
Loa Seki, unfortunately for one of you this will be your last challenge. Tribal Council will be posted shortly.